User blog:Mrs. Loomis/Brooke and Audrey are the killers

Why Brooke is one of the killers which may only be revealed in Season 2
• She knew who Kieran was before anyone had the official introduction. This is what she said in the pilot episode: “His name is Kieran, he just moved here from Atlanta”. How would Brooke know this? Maybe they are both in on it together, or she just has great killer quality, being all-knowing and that wink emoticon

• Brooke envied Nina! Her and Seth Branson’s discussion in the pilot episode strikes me as odd, this is their conversation: Seth: “I know this is a rough week for you (he is referring to Nina’s death), how are you holding up?” Brooke: “Devastated, of course.” Seth: “Right! Well, with the investigation and all, I feel that we should discontinue our…study sessions.” (More about Seth and Brooke later) Brooke clearly has no remorse for Nina’s death in that ep, or ever. I thought they were best friends? Nope, Brooke was jealous and envied Nina, she wanted to be queen bee, but she couldn’t while Queen Nina was around. Even in episode 3, we see Brooke using Nina’s lipstick. Riley was very shocked that Brooke had her lipstick, as if to imply that Nina would never share that lipstick – It’s a mean girl thing! Lol. So, how does Brooke have it? Right, she killed Nina =p Not to mention the fact the Nina blackmailed her family with those videos… she has too many reasons to want Nina and Tyler dead!

Brooke and her relationship with Will
Brooke told Will that: “You better make this right, Will. You messed with the wrong family”. Why would she say that? Her mother is a junkie and never around, her father is clearly not crazy, he would have killed Will because of that video if he were psycho, so they aren’t very scary, and ppl have messed with her family and gotten away with it (*cough* JAKE). So, who is left? Right, Brooke. So, what she actually meant to say is, you messed with the wrong person in the Maddox family lol that being Brooke, of course. If Brooke isn’t the killer, then why is her family story so important, compared to all the other characters, besides Emma? I think her family has A LOT more secrets than which meets the eye. Maybe the Maddox, Anderson and James families are all connected, somehow, just can’t figure it out, yet.

Back to Brooke and Will. Brooke outed Will to Emma, TWICE! First, she outed him in front of Audrey (her accomplice, more about that later) and Emma, and the second time she outed Will in the café where Emma works, she said to Jake, well, she practically screamed this: “I cant keep lying to Emma!” She knew Emma was there and working, it was all part of her plan to make sure Emma heard her, so that she could out Will, just look at her facial expression. What an evil bitch! Lol. I think Brooke is just a sour Bitch, and she wants Emma to feel her pain, she could have told Emma these things ages ago, why now? When the killings start? She wants to bring Emma down down down, especially when she is already so down lol. I think Brooke was pissed that Will ended up liking Emma when they made that bet, she wanted Will at that time. Brooke is jealous of Emma’s popularity. Remember how sad Brooke was sitting by the stream in ep 4, because she saw that poll where everyone voted for her to die next and for Emma to survive. That really made her sad and depressed, as she wants to be the queen bee, the main attraction, but Emma keeps winning. Listen to the scene in Episode 5 when Ghostface calls Emma... That GF sounds exactly like a Brooke, before GF even talked, he played Emma a recording of her talking to Will outside the café, Emma said: “We’re not friends! We’re not together! We’re done!” Brooke could have totally slipped something in Emma’s bag to record that conversation, either way, she was closeby. Going back to the Will and Brooke thing, remember when Will said this to Brooke in the garage: “If you ever come between Emma and me like that again, I will BREAK you”. Poor Will, he should have never threatened Brooke like that, cause she literally BROKE him in half in episode 7 lol, yep, that was Brooke ladies and gentlemen, ;-) Also, if Brooke and Emma are so close, then why in the hell would she sleep over at JAKE’S house in episode 9?? He lied to her and blackmailed her family, she was not in a place to forgive Will, but Jake? Especially after he meticulously lied to her, unlike Will. Again, I think Brooke despises Emma (and maybe even Maggie) so much, that she won’t even sleep over!!! By the way, the reason Brooke is so forgiving with Jake, is because she knew about the videos before he mentioned it, she knew he was lying to him, she said he sounded sketch for a reason, just rewatch that scene in ep 5 =) Jake was also the one who spied on her in ep 9, it wasn't the killer, we all know Jake is a perv by now. She is going to implicate him before killing him lol, just wait for it. Also, that body that the mayor dragged out, I totally think Brooke had something to do with it, she is just playing innocent, like crazy!! What if the mayor is not really her father? She is so rude to him, and all he does is try to help the family. Se could care less. But I have no solid clues pointing there yet =p

Lets look at the meaning of the name, Brooke

 * The series is a bit inspired by the Shelia Eddy case, where TWO GIRLS kill their friend. Brooke's surname (Maddox) has two d's in it, just like Shelia Eddy, maybe a clue, maybe not? The names Brooke and Billy (killer in Scream 1) both start with the letter B, maybe a clue, maybe not?


 * The name Brooke means: “Lives by the stream. People with this name have a deep inner desire to lead, organize, supervise, and to achieve status, power and wealth”. That pretty much sums up how I feel about Brooke. 1) She literally lives by the stream lol. 2) She really wants power and status, and she is willing to screw over/kill everyone to get it. What I find really interesting, is that Brooke has been in close proximity or has been chased by Ghostface 3 times, and she is still alive. HHhmm, that theatre scene was all one big ploy to make Mr. Branson look guilty. I think Audrey was the one to chase Brooke on that stage, she could have easily killed her, but she only gave her that typical slash where the one killer tries to make the other killer look innocent. Also, I think Brooke was craving the attention, but then it went to Seth and Emma, so she got really depressed again in episode 9, where she even told Emma: “I am done being the victim” She had a total bitch look on her face, Emma even said bye so nicely, and Brooke just hung up like a cow. She is not going to play the victim anymore, because she is not getting any attention from being the victim lol, only Emma. So, Emma, yet again, upstages Brooke, even though she is the one with slash on her arm. Also, in that theatre scene where Mr Branson gets “busted”, seth says: “The killer is still out there” and then the sheriff replies: “Yeah, right in front of me”, but Brooke was actually standing right in front of him lol, not Seth, go rewatch. Also, when Brooke called Emma from the liquor store, she said to emma: “Change of plans”, it reminded me of the way the killer told Emma: “change of plans” in the scene where, surprise surprise, Will dies. She is very sketchy. Also, the reason she did not kill Piper, is because she wants Piper to tell her story, she wants Piper to out her family, but make her look like the angel, just look at how Brooke was begging for Piper’s sympathy in episode 8 at the police station, and it actually worked, look at Pipers sad face, she totally feels sorry for Brooke, now, just as Brooke wanted. ;-) Brooke wants to be in the spotlight, and Piper is just the person to help put her there, that’s why Piper is still alive, I don’t think Piper is the main killer.

I think Audrey is Brooke’s accomplice, and will be revealed as one of the killers in the season 1 finale
Audrey hated Nina, cause Nina always bullied her, she also has a lot of reasons to want the popular crowd dead, that is Tyler and Nina for the video release of her and Rachael, Riley (I think Audrey killed Riley, Brooke did not want her too, cause Brooke is not threatened by Riley at all, Brooke knows she will be queen bee over Riley and she did like her, but Audrey led Brooke to the Hotel, while Brooke thought Seth lured her there for some spanky, Audrey actually fooled Brooke… Its only fair, If Rachael had to die, then Riley had to die too) and both of them did not like Will very much, that’s obvious. In that ep when Riley dies :(, Brooke tells Emma that she is in a nightmare of her own making, I think that's referring to her being the killer, not the whole Seth thing. We all know Audrey said the killer could easily be female, she has a voice changer app, she kicked Wills ass in defense class, so she is tough enough. She is also ver pro-female, she likes a tough girl, in ep when Emma held her own about the sex tape thing in class when those kids were making fun of them, Audrey was very impressed! Just look at her face. GF did say: "I like a strong female lead" That definitely sounds like an Audrey. And remember when Audrey said to Noah: “I sense an unholy alliance”, just as she says that the camera jumps from her to Brooke, suggesting Audrey and Brooke are the unholy alliance. Lets be real, between Audrey and Noah, one of them has to be the killer, and I think its Audrey. Audrey always finds the clues, which she obviously planted, she pretends to not be as smart as Noah when it comes to computer stuff, but I think she is lying, I think she also made Emma’s sex tape go viral, as revenge. She knows about cameras and digital stuff and computers. In that ep, she says to Emma, and “you are the star of the show”, then Audrey has this grin when she says to Emma that there is some karmic justice at play in the following ep, then she walks away, angrily, when Will approaches her and Emma, and then she calls Emma with her voice changer app we know she has, and as GF she says, again: “Hello, Emma. How’s it feel to be the star of the show?”. Yep, that was vengeful Audrey. Audrey has all of Racheal’s videos she is so eager to make Kieran and Mr Branson seem guilty. Brooke was also not impressed in the first episode, when Mr. Branson said they had to discontinue their studying sessions, so she seduced him to keep him close, she and Audrey wanted to implicate him, and what I find funny is that the teacher stood her down in that ep, yet another blow to Brooke's ego =p I just don’t know how Audrey would fit in to the Brandon James story, maybe that part is reserved for Brooke, or one of the guys and Audrey is just out for revenge on the popular crowd. But, Audrey did have that sketch of Brandon James.

Kieran or Seth for the guy who helps them. Like the movie Wild Things
Both are dodgy. One of them had to be the killer at the bowling Alley! More on them later.

The Ghostface calls to Emma
Ghostface has told Emma that he/she is "A friend", what if that friend is Brooke and Audrey =). The killers also want Emma to know the truth, and etc etc etc.

THIS THEORY IS A WORK IN PROGRESS, WILL CONTINUE LATER.

Sidenotes

 * The theories mentioned above is what I'd like to happen. But if Noah or Emma should be revealed, how surprising would that be. 😜 Judging by that photo of the finale, it looks like it is between Audrey and Piper for the reveal, both have ears that match somewhat imo, and we can think of a million reasons why Piper could be a killer too. In that bowling Alley scene where GF tries to break through the door where Brooke, Noah and Will was at, GF's arm looked female, and it was clearly not Brooke, and Audrey was with the cops and Maggie, so that may have been Piper. Although, I don't want that, cause Piper is my favourite character 😜