User blog:Kicior94/Dispelling the myth that Kieran is a killer

Hi guys,

So I was checking out the theories that some of you have made, and as much as I enjoyed most of them and they are all interesting, I prefer to go the 'Sherlock Holmes road' and use the deduction and elimination rather than creating the stories. So I am creating this thread to actually try to dispel the theory that Kieran might be a killer.

First some the most interesting theories I saw:

the theory that Kieran Wilcox has died in the car accident and the one we see is impersonanted by Troy James. Well, Maggie claims to know Troy and so should Sheriff Acosta and other people, so I cannot think that this is it. He would have been revealed long time ago.

Kieran is working with Eli and Kieran tries to put a blame on him because Eli had fallen in love with Emma and wants to save her which interferes with Kieran's plan. That also seems to me a little unlikely mainly due to the episode when they were all under the influence of Ayahuasca. There was an attack and they were both in house during that time. That does not give alibi to neither of them ( they still can be a partner of someone's else but they do not work with each other).

Since it has been revealed that most( if not all) homicides were commited by Piper, we can start by dispelling the theory that Piper and Kieran worked together or they were in love with each other. If Kieran was Piper's accomplice/acquaintance or whatever, why would she kill his father? He would have confronted her immediately. Also, if they were partners why would she attack her in season 1 when Will and Piper met with Mayor? He could have just stunned Will and take him (the script writer must have had a reason to show us a scene when she is being attacked and point to us that there actually may be two people who are using the same myth of Brandon James for other purposes but they do not know each other).

Rachel was a filming geek. She was known to really only interact with Audrey. Audrey seemed to find a friend in Piper and it seems likely to think that she might have confessed to Piper about their doings ( that is why killer knows where is and how to lure Rachel to 'Audrey and Rachel spot'). We know that Piper was at Crescent Palms with Audrey at the time of Rachel's death but since we assume that the Kieran& Piper theory is dispelled, Piper must had have the other accomplice. Death of Rachel Murray is the only killing that is not really linked to others and there may lie a key to untie the chain of events. It is actually really mysterious. But to me it had to be someone who knew both her and Audrey well and that person would not be Kieran.

Kieran in many situations appeared 'out of blue' but... Every time the murder scene was searched. How is he to change so quickly and hide&dump costume and weapon so well that the specialised team is not able to find anything? In most of the situations he would have 10-15 seconds TOPS to do everything. He would have to: -Change -Hide and dump the costume and weapon -Find a way to go around the scene of interest without being seen by anyone.

Seems pretty much for so little time, isn't it?

Haley at the party was indoubtedly killed by a man (they had a romance going on) and it really does not seem she would have a romance with NEITHER Kevin Duval nor Kieran. And on top of all that, Kieran was at that time with Noah so he could not have done that.

Also about Kevin being a killer, why would he kill someone in his own room and how was he to plant the murder weapon in Audrey's car if he was with police?

To finish it all of it, the character of the ghostface seems to be maniacal and cynic... Totally opposite to Kieran's personality. Secondly, the posture of ghostface is to small to be Kieran's who is a huge man. And just the smallest thing... It would not be a shocking ending at all to anyone viewer and we have already seen that this is not what this show is about... :) please share your thoughts