User blog:ScaryMovie53/Scream 5's theories board

"Scream 5" is on its way, and i've decided to write down the best theories about the film. If Noah can have a murder board, i can have a theory board. If anyone have another theory, feel free to say it in the comments.

Theory 1 - Requiem for childhood
The final girl and the killer will be hispanic half-sisters. The good sister will be Samantha Carpenter (Melissa Barrera), who'll be hated by the whole town after being accused at killing a child. She obviously didn't do it. The real culprit is her half-sister Tara Carpenter (Jenna Ortega). Tara killed the poor child for the sole reason of framing her sister. Aside from framing her own sister at doing the unthinkable, Tara is also a drug dealer. That's your truly's main theory.

Theory 2 - Troy James have a son
5cream will connect the movies and the TV series using Troy James' secret son, who'll be played by Jack Quaid. Jack looks as if he could be Troy's son. Maybe he could turn out to be Third Killer for his own reasons. It's also combining both Kevin and Troy, in a sense that Jack will have Troy's bloodline and Kevin's deep motives. I know this theory is crazy, but it's interesting enough to work.

Theory 3 - Dewey and Gale's lost baby
In the original "Scre4m", the good people wanted to add Dewey and Gale's baby, until they realized they won't be able to do any filming around him/her. Now, the baby could return in 5cream as a major plot device. Those of you who played TellTale's "The Walking Dead" are familiar with AJ, who was Clementine's adopted son and morality pet. The lost baby might or might not be a morality pet, but he/she is likely to be a major character. If we really want to get wild, there might a sub-plot where Gale cheated on Dewey with Troy James, and now Jack is both Troy's son and the lost "Scre4m" baby.

Theory 4 - The Perkins went psycho
One of the killers might be related to the victims of "Scream 4", blaming Sidney, Dewey and Gale for not being able to save their loved one who were killed by Jill and Charlie. My best guess for this theory is Jasmin Savoy Brown's character (Mindy Meeks-Martin). In this theory, she's the daughter of Anthony Perkins, who disregards the fact Sidney avenged her (Mindy's) father in favor of hating her both for not saving her father and for being Jill's cousin. It's not my main guess (my main theory is still the first theory mentioned in this blog), but the Mindy Meeks-Martin being secretly a Perkins theory (the Jasmine Perkins theory for short) starts to sound reasonable enough. The Jasmin Perkins theory is based on the following points:


 * In several points in the franchise, they had plans to writing a female black killer. In "Scream 2". Hallie was supposed to be one of Debbie's soldiers alongside with Derek, until the good people realized it will be too crazy and used the "leaked on the internet" excuse to change it without admitting they were wrong. Season 3 would've make more sense with Liv as the killer. In their defence, they did write Jamal as the most obvious ghostface so far. Mindy could be what Liv was supposed to be, but more tragic.


 * Not everyone can live with the fact their parents are idiots. The whole subtext of Billy killing Maureen before the retcon was a stupid boy who blamed the lover at the sins of the father. Mindy might blame Sidney in her father's death so she won't have to deal with her father's stupidity. I know the fanbase might eat me alive for saying it, but Mindy's motive makes better sense than Billy's.


 * Most killers were obvious to an extent, but they were meant to be mysterious before the reveal, even if they were obvious on purpose for eliminating suspecions. Mindy can be the most surprising option. Randy also mentioned that a black girl as a killer is against the rules, but not completely. It could be a reference to Randy, which will be a nice meta joke.


 * Since her father was a cop, it's very likely that she knew her way with firearms to an extent. It makes her even more similar to Liv, whose father was also a cop.


 * Mindy working with Tara (the drug dealer half-sister)/Jack (Troy James' lost son) is faithful to the tradition of killers with conflicting motives who are also dangerous to each other. The question of this point is whether she's more likely to work with Tara, or more likely to work with Jack.

This is the most well-developed theory so far, but i still lean to believe that theory 1 is the most likely one.

Theory 5 - The Perkins went psycho 2
Everything i said in the former theory, except for Chad instead of Mindy.

update to theory 5
The trailer shows us the killer chasing and probably killing Chad. Maybe Chad faked his death.

Final conclusion
Turns out my theory about Richie being a killer wad right, even if not for the reasons i though. Also, Amber was the fake red herring. Samantha was the real red herring.